Skip to main content

Plano Statement on Women's Ordination

I'm still reading this thing, and want to understand it thoroughly. I have read enough, at this point, to note that they disdain biblical exegesis of implied meaning as "weak" and therefore insufficient to counter their arguments for women's ordination. At one point, they quote the esteemed Jefferson Davis on slavery as a way of arguing their point. It is evident that their thinking is clouded.

First of all, it is the Reformed position that Biblical truth is equally authoritative be it expressly stated or derived by "good and necessary consequence."* Now, the reformers knew the laws of Logic; they were classically educated. They knew that there was such a thing as a bad use of Logic. They believed that if something in Scripture could be proven by "good and necessary consequence", not just any consequence, then it was to be held. In this, they follow the example of the Lord Jesus Himself in Matthew 22 when he confronted the Saducees for not knowing the Scriptures. Jesus quotes a verse that has nothing expressly to do with the Resurrection and holds the Saducees at fault for not seeking the appropriate "good and necessary consequence" of God's word.

Secondly, the irony of the Jefferson Davis quote is that Davis is listing express statements of Scripture! The Bible expressly affirms what Davis is saying. Therefore, to use Davis as an example of the weakness of implied meaning of Scripture is for the authors of this paper to turn their argument upon its own head. Indeed, it was the implications of Scripture that lead to the Christian position against slavery! The authors of this paper on women's ordination are failing to use "good and necessary consequence" in their arguments and therefore - at least in this portion of their paper - failing to prove their position.

* Vide The Westminster Confession of Faith, I. vi.

Comments

My statement about Davis's listing express statements needs a little editing. He is not referring to Scripture in the whole of his list. He begins and moves on from there. Anyone familiar with the arguments of that day regarding slavery know exactly what passages of Scripture Davis has in mind.
Anonymous said…
Nice brief and this post helped me alot in my college assignement. Say thank you you seeking your information.
Anonymous said…
Good post and this fill someone in on helped me alot in my college assignement. Gratefulness you on your information.

Popular posts from this blog

Courageous Leadership - Evensong, June, 2023

The texts are Joshua 24 and Galatians 2.

A Sea Shanty for St. Michael and All Angels

Audio of the song   “He Made the Devil Fall” - a “Sea Shanty” (Luke 10:18; Rev. 20:10) Beckmann, Feast of St. Michael and All Angels, 2023 Jesus, he came to Galilee And he made the devil fall! And called the twelve to with him be. And he made the devil fall! Refrain: He made the devil fall, my boys, He makes the devil fall! Christ the King will come again, And he’ll make the devil fall! Ho!   To them his pow'r was freely giv'n, And he made the devil fall! And Satan fell like light’ning from heav'n, And he made the devil fall!  He purged our sins; his vict'ry won! And he made the devil fall! And rose again to take his throne. And he made the devil fall!  He sent St. Michael with his sword, And he made the devil fall! And cast that dragon to the earth, And he made the devil fall!  He’ll send an angel, the devil to take And he’ll make the devil fall! And cast him into the fiery lake! And he’ll make the devil fall!

What is Evensong?

 Here are a few articles explaining the Anglican tradition of Evensong: From Ad Fontes:  https://christhum.wordpress.com/2013/11/26/liturgy-bits-a-spotters-guide-to-evensong/ Here's an article on Evensong from Classic FM:  https://www.classicfm.com/discover-music/what-is-evensong-how-long-service/ The Religious News Service:  https://religionnews.com/2017/08/30/evensong-sees-a-surge-even-as-british-church-attendance-declines/ From choralevensong.org/uk:   https://www.choralevensong.org/uk/about-choral-evensong-724.php For some reason, you have to go to "Read More" to use the links. It helps to differentiate between "Evensong" proper, which is the Evening Prayer service sung by officiants and congregation, and "Choral Evensong", which is the Evening Prayer mostly sung by a choir.